08 Oct 2016 20:06:45
Indians get McCutchen OF
Pirates get Mejia (4) C Hillman (11) LHP Mathias (16) 2B/ 3B Allen (19) OF Sanander (30) OF/ 1B

Why it makes sense for Indians, they need a reliable all star out fielder.
Why it makes sense for Pirates they have Marte who can play CF and there has been reports they are going to part ways with McCutchen.

1.) 08 Oct 2016
08 Oct 2016 20:32:55
I strongly doubt the Pirates move McCutchen for that cheap.

2.) 08 Oct 2016
08 Oct 2016 20:38:34
I think McCutcheon to Cleveland makes some sense, but the Tribe would have to send a SP to Pittsburgh. I think Trevor Bauer in place of a couple of these prospects might get it done.

3.) 08 Oct 2016
08 Oct 2016 20:46:22
I don't think the Indians are the right place. When Urshela comes up and plays third, they'll put Ramirez in left when they decline Brantley's 2018 club option. Rajai Davis has been good in center field and I think it would be good to re-sign him this offseason.

Should he get traded, I think some of the top places he could go are: Texas (they have Desmond and Beltran leaving as free agents) and Seattle.