MLB talk 3


Use our rumors form to send us mlb trade rumors.

(single word yields best result)

If you didn't know, we have a NBA trade rumors site and a NFL trade rumors site

24 Jan 2017 22:20:20
Sorry to al Twins fan for not being able to get the dodgers to trade for Dozier, your GM must have been crazy to want calhoun and de leon together.

P. S I prefer forsythe than dozier

Agree3 Disagree2

25 Jan 2017 19:48:35
Ps you're insane Dozier is easily the best second baseman, excellent power, should've won MVP this past season or at least finished in top 3. He's a top 15 player imo Forsythe doesn't even crack top 100

25 Jan 2017 22:08:44
I agree with Mamba. There's no one on around baseball who realistically sees Forsythe as better.

The Dodgers moved on to Forsythe after they failed to get Dozier in a 1-for-1 move. It was known all along they favored Dozier.

26 Jan 2017 23:59:59
Listen to how his teammates are talking about Forsythe. Evan Longoria is upset with them trading him. Over the past few seasons they are comparable in WAR. Yeah Doizer hit 42 HRs last season but i would bank on Forsythe to stay consistant

29 Jan 2017 05:31:56
What does his clubhouse reputation have to do with his talent level?

Dozier is equally beloved by most of the Twins clubhouse. Your point is moot.

21 Jan 2017 15:13:06
Every pitcher in the MLB became a free agent. Yet they're only willing to sign a one year deal. You're a GM. What's your top 10 big board look like?


1) Kershaw
2) Scherzer
3) Bumgarner
4) Sale
5) Syndergaard
6) Kluber
7) Verlander
8) Hendricks
9) Cueto
10) Porcello

*I think you could make an argument for putting 2-6 in any order

*Hendricks is great but not in that top group until he can consistently pitch into the 7th

*Honorable mentions: Tanaka, Lester, Quintana, Roark, Sanchez

Agree0 Disagree2

22 Jan 2017 16:49:11
What about Price

22 Jan 2017 20:56:01
He's very good no doubt. Probably should've been mentioned in honorable mentions but other than innings (which is very valuable don't get me wrong) he didn't rank top 10 or even 20 in almost any of the advanced stats last year. Even his WHIP, ERA and FIP were worst of his career since 09.

23 Jan 2017 00:27:21
1. MadBum
2. Kershaw
3. Scherzer
4. Syndergaard
5. Sale
6. Kluber
7. Archer
8. Arrieta
9. Martinez
10. Tillman

Madbum above Kershaw, mainly because of playoffs, both are great in regular season but Madbum is that guy I know can dominate in the playoffs.

Archer he's very very good just on a really really bad team.

Martinez one of the best young pitchers

Tillman has dominated the AL East no doubt he'd do the same in any other divison

24 Jan 2017 05:37:54
I love Bumgarner as much as the next guy, but you can't possibly believe he's better than Kershaw.

25 Jan 2017 01:24:50
Tillman is not even in the top 20.

No one is better than Kershaw right now. I don't want to hear anything it is not a question.

Archer is a very good pitcher but as of right now he is not in the top 10.

Aaron Sanchez won the AL ERA title at the age of 24 in his first full season starting.

Cueto has to be up there. No question

25 Jan 2017 15:24:07
Zammer, what's your top 10 looking like?

25 Jan 2017 19:52:35
Tillman is one of the best he's had a era of 3.50 or lower in the past 5 out of 6 seasons I believe and he's pitching in the AL East the dude is a stud.

If Archer actually had a good team behind him I'd say he has the potential to be the third best starter

MadBum Kershaw debate, I love Kershaw but both are great in regular season but MadBum is flat out dominate in postseason. Same thing with Archer is Giants scored more he'd be putting up Kershaw numbers

25 Jan 2017 22:04:42
Tillman isn't even the best pitcher on his own team.

25 Jan 2017 23:57:54

If i was only to sign 1 of them to a one year deal, Kershaw is number 1 no doubt. I chose Synergaard over MadBum because i feel there is still improvement with Synergaard while MadBum is going to be consistently the same. The last 2 picks in Sanchez and Martinez are 2 really young pitchers who have already dominated and i expect them to take it to the next level

26 Jan 2017 01:50:36
Verlander over Kluber and Sale?

26 Jan 2017 02:45:04
Zammer, are you a Blue Jays fan? As a Canadien, it's the only way I can see someone putting Sanchez in the top 10. He's not better than Arrieta, Lester, or even deGrom.

26 Jan 2017 04:12:53
Verlander should have won the AL Cy Young over Porcello

26 Jan 2017 04:15:54
Tillman has had an ERA under 3.50 twice in the last 2 seasons and 1 of those seasons he only started 15 games. He has a career ERA of 4.15. He hasn't dominated the AL East

26 Jan 2017 12:44:20
Fair enough, agree to disagree about Verlander.

But exposfan, Jake is not a top 10 pitcher, probably not top 15 imo. I'd take Sanchez over him rn as well. He had an amazing run for about 20 games and started the season strong but after that has come down to earth. Era was above 4 closing out this season and failed to hit 200 innings.

26 Jan 2017 19:48:17
This is about taking a pitcher on a 1 year deal. Lester is one of the top 10 in the game but he has a ton of innings on his arm and is on the wrong side of 30. Arietta struggled with control and was not the same dominant self. DeGrom is coming on an injury season where he struggled down the stretch.

02 Feb 2017 01:24:38

02 Feb 2017 16:11:19
You could also argue that Sanchez doesn't have enough of a track record to buy in on a 1-year deal.

I think Sanchez is very, very good. I don't think he's anywhere close to a top 10 pitcher.

03 Feb 2017 22:21:44
Hasnt had a bad season yet and had the lowest in the AL in his first full season as a starter? i'd bet on that any day. Aaron Sanchez is that good man.

08 Feb 2017 20:07:20
1. Kershaw
2. Scherzer
3. Bumgarner
4. Kluber
5. Lester
6. Sale
7. Verlander
8. Hendricks
9. Cueto
10. Syndergaard

Syndergaard could very likely be higher than this after the season, but he just hasn't played enough yet for me and we will see if he can stay healthy. and I'm sorry, but Mamba you're crazy if you think Tillman is near the top 10 in all of baseball.

13 Feb 2017 23:38:33
Puts Lester over Sale like a true cubs fan lol.

19 Jan 2017 18:47:23
I could see the White Sox adding someone like Hanigan on a 1 years deal. He is a great veteran presence and is a great defender and can really help their young pitchers develop. The White Sox aren't going anywhere this season not are they going any where the season after that so they should do everything they can to help develop their young guys and adding Hanigan would do just that.

What do you guys think?

Agree0 Disagree2

19 Jan 2017 21:33:25
sull i'm going to try to be nice about this, but who really cares about these insignificant signings as much as you do?

20 Jan 2017 21:32:28
Hanigan would be better than anyone the white sox have at catcher now.

22 Jan 2017 01:31:38
That was my thinking

23 Jan 2017 22:52:06
The Sox need to acquire a young catcher in a trade in case Collins doesn't turn out to stay behind the plate.

18 Jan 2017 15:42:43
Pirates should bring Jason Rogers back on a minor league deal. There is a good chance that Kang gets suspended and that would probably force Freese and Frazier to platoon at 3rd and they could use some depth at 1st. Bringing back Rogers on a minor league deal should be done even if Kang isn't suspended because he can play some 3rd as well and some corner outfield. But he would be a cheap insurance policy for the Pirates and I think it makes too much sense.

What do you guys think? (personally I think this is my most believable post yet)

Agree1 Disagree4

18 Jan 2017 17:57:08
who is jason rogers?

19 Jan 2017 13:03:44
The guy they traded for last offseason from the Brewers and gave up Keon Broxton to get him. That's who, they DFAd him earlier this offseason

19 Jan 2017 15:33:54
idk, he seems rather insignificant to me. I think there are better options sull.

20 Jan 2017 14:52:16
You believe your most believable post yet is saying a guy who got DFAd and no one knows about him will be a starter LOL that's hilarious man, might as well have the guy of the men's softball team in Pittsburg start as well eh

22 Jan 2017 01:33:00
I never said that he would start I said he would be good depth behind Freese and Bell now that Rodregez is gone.

03 Feb 2017 02:53:18
They're not going to sign him because he is on the AAA roster, DFA doesn't mean he gets released

16 Jan 2017 18:01:29

Everyone is posting Jay Bruce trades. However, I think he actually could enter the year on the team because the teams interested have filled their needs elsewhere (PHI- Saunders, TOR- Bautista) .

Jeremy Blevins
2 years $16 million

C- Travis d'Arnaud
1B- Lucas Duda
2B- Neil Walker
3B- David Wright
SS- Asdrubal Cabrera
LF- Yoenis Cespedes
CF- Curtis Granderson
RF- Jay Bruce

C- Rene Rivera
IF- Wilmer Flores
IF- Jose Reyes
UT- TJ Rivera
OF- Juan Lagares

SP- Noah Syndergaard
SP- Jacob deGrom
SP- Matt Harvey
SP- Steven Matz
SP- Zach Wheeler

LR- Robert Gsellman
MR- Seth Lugo
MR- Jeremy Blevins
MR- Sean Gilmartin
MR- Hansel Robles
SU- Addison Reed
CL- Jenrys Familia

Let Conforto and Nimmo go down and fine-tune their swings. The Mets have several players who are FA at the end of the year (Duda, Walker, Cabrera, Granderson, Bruce, Reed) who will free up a lot of money. They have young players ready to step in when needed.

Agree0 Disagree0

14 Jan 2017 20:00:41
Remaining Free Agent Predictions

Matt Wieters - Angels
Chris Carter - Royals
Adam Lind - Orioles
Mike Napoli - Rangers
Chase Utley - Dodgers
Luis Valbuena - Braves
Michael Saunders - Reds
Jose Bautista - Blue Jays
Mark Trumbo - Royals
Brett Anderson - Pirates
Doug Fister - Twins
Jason Hammel - Yankees
Joe Blanton - Mets
Greg Holland - Nationals
Sergio Romo - Royals
Jerry Blevins - Diamondbacks
JP Howell - Yankees
Boone Logan - Dodgers
Travis Wood - Phillies

Agree0 Disagree5

15 Jan 2017 17:23:47
Meant to put Carter on the White Sox, not the Royals.

12 Jan 2017 17:51:02
White Sox Receive
DH Evan Gattia
OF Nori Aoki
SP Mike Fiers
1B A J Reed
P David Paulino 4th in Astros System 70th in MLB
OF Derek Fisher 5th in Astros System 83rd in MLB
3B Colin Moran 8th in Astros System
OF Gilberto Celestino 13th in Astros System
Astros Receive
SP Jose Quintana
CL David Robertson
OF Melky Cabrera

Agree0 Disagree7

12 Jan 2017 18:43:31
wow this is good- said no one.

12 Jan 2017 23:16:16
You've definitely done wrong, Doc.

You can't justify getting that return for a bunch of sluff from Houston. Chicago is going to want legitimate talent.

Plus, Chicago would have to DFA 4 players to make room for the added guys coming in (7 of them are on 40-man rosters) .

11 Jan 2017 05:34:01
I as a pirates fan would love for them to acquire Jose Quintana. For the right price. I don't think they should sell the future. So why not:
Sign Brett Anderson 2 years


Agree4 Disagree0

11 Jan 2017 07:14:53
It would be stupid for any team to lock themselves in a deal with Anderson at this point.

He'll continue to sign 1-year deals until he proves he can stay healthy.

11 Jan 2017 13:53:23
Brett Anderson would probably be injured for most of this contract.

11 Jan 2017 14:34:17
Bigbird, Have yet to see a lot of Pirates fans on here discussing the possibility of Q. What would be your final offer as far as "right price"? Just curious as to how far or close fan bases are.

09 Jan 2017 17:55:44
Where is the Jerk?
Is alive?

Agree1 Disagree0

10 Jan 2017 00:03:50
He's as dead as your grammar.

10 Jan 2017 17:29:12
We all know huskers is the jerk

11 Jan 2017 15:17:17
hammer, if you spent half the time on your sleuth skills as you did on baseball knowledge, this website would be a much better place.

13 Jan 2017 13:52:32

Thor is the one with the hammer

08 Jan 2017 13:29:22
I get Jose Quintana is consistent but is that really worth a package more than the sox got for sale I mean Quintanas strikeout numbers aren't high his ip is like 30 innings less than sale so tell me what I'm missing

Agree1 Disagree1

08 Jan 2017 17:59:17
Quintana is not worth a sale package. You're right he's not Sale, But:

Quintana value as a pitcher alone is about 75 on the dollar of Sale. Combine that with the fact that he has longer control for an even lower salary and you're looking to get back 80 to 90 cents on the dollar that Sale gets you back.

Sale getting you the #1 position player prospect and a very high prospect in Kopech as a headliner makes the ChiSox (and their fans) believe that Quintana needs to be headlined by a top 10 prospect OR a couple of top 30-40 prospect guys.

08 Jan 2017 20:10:44
Quintana offers more in the way of contract value. He is cheaper and has an extra year of control remaining than Sale.

He is not as good, but the contract value is certainly there, and honestly, he isn't so much worse that his contract actually makes me probably consider him over Sale.


mlb talk

mlb talk 2

Log In or Register to post

Remember me

Forgot Pass